• Home
  • Thesis
  • Background
  • Workplace Struggles
  • Need for the NCLC
  • Formation of the NCLC
  • Exposing Child Labor
  • Changes To Sentiment
  • Failed Legislation
  • New Deal and Reform
  • Timeline
  • Conclusion
  • Paperwork
                   To Learn or to Earn?
    The National Child Labor Committee and the
             Fight to End Child Exploitation


Workplace Struggles


Spinners and Doffers in Mills

“When my machines get old and useless, I reject them and get new ones and these [children] are part of my machinery” 
-New England Mill Owner [1858]
Young girls employed illegally as spinners worked for eleven to twelve hours a day mending breaks in the threads of the machines.
"I had to clean fallers, which, like teeth, chopped down on one's hand, unless great precautions were used" 
-Al Priddy, former cotton mill child laborer [n.d.]
Picture
Sadie Pfeifer, a cotton mill spinner, has been in the mill one year; she sometimes works at night, all for 48 cents a day in Lancaster, South Carolina [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1908]
Picture
Many of the young boys worked barefoot as it made it easier to climb on to the machine so they could reach the bobbins or broken threads, Macon, Georgia [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1909]
If a bobbin ran out of thread, a boy called a “doffer” would rush to replace it.      The accident rate for children was twice the rate for adults.
"A twelve year old doffer boy fell into the spinning machine and the unprotected gearing tore out two of his fingers. 'We don't have any accidents in this mill,' the overseer told me. 'Once in a while a finger is mashed or a foot, but it don't amount to anything'" 
-NCLC Photographer Lewis Hine [n.d.]
Picture
Giles Edmund Newsom was working at Sanders Cotton Manufacturing Co. in Bessemer City--he lost two of his fingers by falling into a machine while working as a doffer boy [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1912]

Newsies and Salesmen

Picture
7 year old Tommie Nooman demonstrating the advantages of the Ideal Necktie Form in a store window in Washington, D.C [United States National Archives, 1911]
Children working the streets were often seen as enterprising youngsters starting on the road to success.
"He is the youngest demonstrator in America. Has been doing it for several years from San Francisco to New York. We stay a month or six weeks in a place. He works at it off and on" -Father of Tommie Nooman [1911]
However, roaming the streets unsupervised resulted in many young "newsies" adopting bad habits. 
"I grew up on a pool table, I lived on the streets practically all day, days and nights both. We used to sneak into the burlesque houses or the all-night places on West Madison street and sleep there" 
-Philip Marcus, "newsie" [n.d.]
Picture
"Tony Casale, age 11, been selling 4 years, sometimes until 10 p.m, had marks on his arm where his father had bitten him for not selling more papers" [United States National Archives, 1909]

Breaker and Trapper Boys in the Mines

Large numbers of young boys were employed in  coal breakers outside  mines to pick out pieces of slate from the coal.
"The fingers of breaker boys were often bloody, the flesh shredded, from spending long hours picking out sharp-edged slate from a moving conveyor belt. This condition was called red top" 
-Peter Roberts, author of Anthracite Coal Communities [1904]
Picture
The breaker boys, who endured some of the most grueling conditions, came to symbolize all that was wrong with child labor [University of Minnesota, 1909]
Picture
View of the Ewen Breaker of the Pennsylvania Coal Co, South Pittston, Pennsylvania [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1911]
"The dust was so dense at times as to obscure the view and penetrated the utmost recesses of the boys' lungs. A kind of slave-driver sometimes stands over the boys, prodding or kicking them into obedience" -Lewis Hine [1911]
Picture
[Library of Congress NCLC Collection, January 7, 1911]
"Falling into a chute at the Chauncey colliery of the George S. Lee Coal Company at Avondale this afternoon, Dennis McKee, aged fifteen of West Nanticoke was smothered to death and Arthur Allbecker, aged fifteen had both of his legs burned and injured...Both boys were employed as breaker boys, and going too close to their chutes, fell in...When taken out, McKee was found to be dead. His remains were removed to his home at West Nanticoke. Allbecker will recover" [1911]
The work performed by the breaker boys was extremely hazardous,  often  resulting  in  a  loss of limbs and fatal lung diseases.

Working in Agriculture

"Children as young as five were expected to work in agriculture, usually picking or hulling berries. During the first decade of the 1900s, up to fifteen hundred children were employed to harvest one berry crop...because most of these small immigrant children did not speak English, they did not know their boss was cheating them, just as they did not know he would regularly underpay them for their work" -Historian Rebecca Valentine [2007]
Twelve-year-old Lahnert boy topping beets."The boys can keep up with me all right, and all day long," the father said. Begin at 6 a.m. and work until 6 p.m. with hour off at noon. Fort Collins, Colorado [1915]
Norris Luvitt, child who had been picking 3 years in berry fields near Baltimore [1909]
Eight-year-old Jack driving a horse rake. A small boy has difficulty keeping his seat on rough ground and this work is more or less dangerous. Western Massachusetts [1915]
Six-year-old Warren Frakes. Mother said he picked 41 pounds yesterday "An I don't make him pick; he picked some last year." Has about 20 pounds in his bag. Comanche County, Oklahoma [1908]
Three boys, one of 13 yrs., two of 14 yrs., picking shade-grown tobacco on Hackett Farm. The "first picking" necessitates a sitting posture. Buckland, Connecticut [1917]
Camille Carmo, age 7, and Justine, age 9. The older girl picks about 4 pails a day. Rochester, Massachusetts [1908]
click to enlarge and hover to view captions [Library of Congress NCLC Collection]
Picture
Clipping of an article from a local newspaper detailing a young boy's accident while working on a farm with dangerous machinery. [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1915]
"Clinton Stewart, aged 12, son of William Stewart of South Stephentown, N.Y., is at the House of Mercy hospital as the result of an accident he met with last Tuesday. He was operating his father's mowing machine when the machine struck a stone and he was thrown in front of the knives of the mower, which cut his left hand off. He was brought to the hospital and his condition is very satisfactory" [1915]

Sweatshop Workers

"As each girl completed her part the garment was passed on to the next girl by Levinson [the shop boss] who was always walking back and forth urging us on. Should a girl lag behind, he would prod her, sometimes pulling on the garment to hurry it on to another worker. At the end of each week the girl who had turned out the least work was dropped from the payroll. Knowledge of this had the effect of keeping the girls working like mad"

-Immigrant sweatshop worker Marie Ganz [1919]
Picture
Group of sweatshop workers in shop of M. Silverman. 30 Suffolk St., N. Y. [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, Feb. 21, 1908]
Picture
Children stitch garments at individual work stations in a loft building in New York--despite its spacious appearance, this sweatshop was no more comfortable than smaller ones [Library of Congress NCLC Collection, 1908]
“The corner of the [sweat]shop would resemble a kindergarten because we were young...it was a world of greed; the human being didn't mean anything. The hours were from 7:30 in the morning to 6:30 at night...we [sometimes] worked until nine o clock. No overtime pay, not even supper money” -Pauline Newman, Triangle Shirtwaist Factory worker [1901]

The harsh reality of working conditions for  child laborers was  largely  unknown to most Americans.  Due to this,  there was no support from the public for  labor to be regulated.

Previous: Background
Next: Need for the NCLC
Thesis: 
The leadership of the National Child Labor Committee piloted the social reform movement against the exploitation of children. By harnessing the power of propaganda to influence public opinion, the NCLC changed society’s perception, thus allowing for the passage of national legislation prohibiting the labor of children. The legacy of the NCLC lies not only in ending child labor,  but also in establishing a  precedent for  future federal regulation of labor. 
Niharika Boinpally and Divya Pakianathan
Senior Group Website
Word Count (Student Composed): 1166
Process Paper Word Count: 484